By: Dr. Abdul Wadud Nafis, Lc., MEI
Islamic socialism is an idea that seeks to integrate Islamic values with the struggle for social justice, economic equality, and the defense of the mustadh’afin (the oppressed and marginalized). However, behind this idealism lies a critical question: Is Islamic socialism truly an instrument for liberating the poor, or does it potentially serve as an ideological justification for political interests and the pursuit of power? A study by Lin Hongxuan published in the Journal of Southeast Asian Studies (2024) indicates that several Indonesian Muslim thinkers have embraced ideas of social justice and economic solidarity without necessarily accepting Marxist communism in its entirety.
- Economic Justice as a Social Imperative
Indonesia’s socioeconomic data demonstrate that the struggle for economic justice remains relevant. Statistics Indonesia (BPS) reported that, as of September 2025, the number of people living in poverty reached 23.36 million, or 8.25 percent of the population, while the Gini ratio stood at 0.363. Although poverty and inequality have declined, the problem of equitable wealth distribution remains unresolved. The Jakarta Post has also highlighted that declining poverty rates do not automatically eliminate inequality, particularly in urban areas. These facts indicate that critiques of capitalism and demands for distributive justice have an empirical foundation; however, addressing economic problems does not necessarily require adopting a single ideological framework.
- Islam and the Instruments of Distributive Justice
From an Islamic perspective, economic justice is a moral and theological obligation, not merely a political agenda. Zakat, infak, sadaqah, waqf, the prohibition of riba, and the principles of trustworthiness and justice provide mechanisms for wealth redistribution without abolishing private property rights or freedom of enterprise. Therefore, Islamic socialism should be evaluated based on its effectiveness in reducing poverty, expanding economic opportunities, and improving public welfare, rather than merely on its rhetoric of defending the people. When religion is used as a vehicle for political power, the struggle for justice risks turning into ideological manipulation.
- Justice or Political Interests?
Ultimately, Islamic socialism stands at a crossroads between the ideal of justice and the realities of politics. Its commitment to the mustadh’afin must be translated into measurable, transparent, equitable, and welfare-oriented policies. Islam does not legitimize power that claims to represent the people while neglecting its responsibilities. **Economic justice is not a tool for gaining power; it is a moral responsibility that must be upheld by whoever holds power.
